Fire Service Instruction with Eric Makowski

Straight talk on fire service instruction

Passing a Student Who Isn’t Ready Isn’t Kindness

By Eric Makowski


It’s the last evolution of the last day. The class has worked hard, the paperwork is ready to sign, and one student still can’t do the skill. Everybody on the training ground can see it, including the student. What the instructor does in the next five minutes says more about the program than anything in the syllabus.

The easy signature

The pressure to pass that student is real. Their chief sent them and expects them back certified. They’re a good person who showed up every day and tried. The class has been a good one, and nobody wants to end it on a hard conversation. Signing the sheet takes two seconds. Telling them no takes a lot longer.

So the instructor talks themselves into it. They’ll pick it up on the job. Their company officer will finish them off. It was close enough.

Here’s the problem with close enough. A certificate is a promise. It tells a crew, an officer and the public that this person can do this job. When we sign for somebody who can’t, we aren’t doing them a favor. We’re sending them into a situation they aren’t prepared for and handing the risk to whoever is standing next to them when it goes wrong. On a fire, that’s a crewmember. On an aircraft, it might be a passenger waiting on a rescue that isn’t coming fast enough.

I’ve been in this service a long time, and I’ve never heard anyone say they wished their instructor had been easier on them once they got to a real fire.

Fair starts on day one

Failing someone fairly doesn’t begin at the end of the course. It begins before the first evolution.

A student can only be held to a standard they know about. That means the performance objectives are written down, handed out and explained in plain language. Here’s the skill. Here’s the time limit or the condition. Here’s what passing looks like and what doesn’t. If the standard lives only in the instructor’s head, then every evaluation becomes an opinion, and opinions are easy to argue with.

It also means every student gets measured against the same standard by every instructor. If one evaluator passes a tight hose-line advance and another fails the same performance, the problem isn’t the student. Get your cadre together before the class and agree on what you’re looking for. Use a checklist or a skill sheet. Write down what you saw, not just the result.

Nobody should be surprised

The student who fails on the last day should never be hearing about the problem for the first time on the last day.

When you see someone struggling, tell them early and tell them specifically. Don’t say “you need to work on your ladder raises.” Say “the butt of the ladder is kicking out on the raise, and the ladder is drifting before the fly ever goes up.” Then give them the reps to fix it. Pull them aside during a break. Pair them with a strong student. Build extra time into the schedule if you can.

Document that too. Note what you saw, what you told them and what you did to help. That record protects the student, the instructor and the program. If the student doesn’t make it, there’s a clear trail showing they were told, coached and given a fair shot.

Most students who are struggling will close the gap once someone shows them exactly where it is. The ones who still can’t get there after real coaching are the ones who aren’t ready yet. That’s information, not a judgment on them as a person.

How to deliver the no

When it’s time to tell a student they didn’t meet the standard, do it in private, do it directly and do it with respect.

  1. Say it plainly. “You didn’t meet the standard on this skill today.” Don’t wrap it in so much padding that they walk away unsure what happened.
  2. Point to the standard. Show them the objective and what you observed. Keep it about the performance, not the person.
  3. Give them a path. Tell them exactly what they need to work on and how they can be re-evaluated, whether that’s a retest, a remedial session or the next class.
  4. Close the loop with their department. Their officer or training officer needs to know what happened and what the plan is. They should hear it from you, not secondhand.

Be ready for emotion. Frustration, embarrassment, even anger are normal. Let them have it, stay calm and stay on the facts. A lot of firefighters who failed a skill once came back and became the best on their crew at it. Being held to a standard can be the moment a student decides to take the job seriously.

The standard is the respect

Holding the line on a student who isn’t ready is one of the hardest parts of this job. It’s also one of the most important. Every student who graduates from your program carries your signature onto a fireground. Make sure it means something.

Set the standard early. Coach hard. Document honestly. When someone isn’t ready, tell them the truth and show them the way back. That isn’t being tough on people. That’s taking them seriously.

Stay safe, and train like it matters.

Eric Makowski

Eric Makowski has spent 29 years in the fire service and writes every Monday, Wednesday and Friday about fire instruction: how we teach, how we train, and how we can do both better. More about Eric →

Leave a Reply